What Is The Best Bay Rum Aftershave In 2021?

Last Updated: Nov 4, 2021

If you are in a hurry and just want to find out what the best bay rum aftershave is, then we recommend the St Johns Aftershave as the best one.

I remember applying my dad’s bay rum aftershave when I was 9 years old. I couldn’t wait to grow my beards as the spice and fragrance of the product is irresistible. Oh, the sense of pride I remember feeling after getting my first bottle of aftershave. Since then, I’ve used the worst, slightly suitable and the best bay rum aftershave.

If you’re looking for a recommendation on the best aftershave, it’s your lucky day because you’re in the right place.

In this article, we’re going to review the following bay rum aftershaves:

What Is Bay Rum Aftershave?

Bay rum is a product with a combination of Jamaican rum, spices, and bay leafs from West Indies. This aftershave is distinctive from others for its spicy woody and sweet scent, leaving a man feel more confident, especially around women.

Bay leafes growing naturally in sunlight
Bay Leafs – Used in Bay Rum

Benefits of Using Bay Rum Aftershave

First, this product has moisturizing qualities, thus minimize wrinkling or outbreak of razor burn. Bay rum has antibacterial, antifungal properties; therefore, a good relieve for skin infections that can occur after shaving. Another advantage of using bay rum is its ability to seal pores preventing bacteria from getting into your skin.

As we all know, dressing well makes you feel confident. Wearing a fragrance boosts the feeling. So, what harm would it cause in looking good and smelling like it too? Use bay rum aftershave to spice and enliven your spirits.

Factors to Consider When Buying Bay Rum Aftershave


Initially, manufacturers extracted bay rum from bay leaves in West Indies. Today, it’s different as companies are using synthetic chemical s to mimic the fragrance of bay leaves from the West Indies. Ensure you check the ingredients on the bottle of your product to confirm whether the manufacturer is using bay leaves or chemicals mimicking the scent.

Another ingredient you should check is the rum. Ensure its Jamaican rum and not SD-40 alcohol or grain alcohol.

 If you have irritation prone skin, ensure the ingredients are a blend of alcohol, purified water, essential oils, and plant extracts. 

best bay rum aftershave


The best bay rum aftershave is characterized by earthy or woody aroma. The scent is intense that your neighbour will smell it if you’re using one. However, the smell soon fades. Another type of bay rum is one with a mild fragrance that lingers longer. Choose accordingly, depending on whether you love strong scents or not.

If you want to leave sillage, walk by choosing a fragrance that lasts longer.

Moisture sealing properties

Even when you don’t have dry skin, it’s vital to choose a product that seals moisture. Product with grain alcohol or SD-40 alcohol dries your skin. Choose an aftershave that contains moisturizing ingredients such as aloe vera, hazel extracts, vitamin C, and glycerine.

Skin type

If you have oily skin, choose a product with a higher percentage of alcohol. On the other hand, if yours is dry, try a product with less alcohol. Also, when you apply the aftershave on dry skin, you’ll note the fragrance is dissipating quickly than on oily skin. So, if you want to use the aftershave as a cologne and you have dry skin, apply on spots that tend to be oily such as behind ears or temples.

Budget and brand

The ingredients in a product determine the price of the end product. Reputable brands, therefore, ensure they use quality ingredients, and thus, their products can be expensive. However, this does not mean you’ll have to break the bank to afford an aftershave. If you’re looking for a budget product, ensure it doesn’t have harsh chemicals or low-quality alcohol.

tropical beach with palm trees and clear water
West Indies – Bay Rum Originates From Here

So, Why Choose Bay Rum and Not Any Other Regular Aftershave?

So far, I’m describing bay rum aftershave as a product with Jamaican rum, bay leaves, and spices, including cinnamon, clove, or citrus. It leaves you feeling a pleasant burning sensation that later becomes soothing heat. But, regular aftershaves are alcohol-based with added fragrances, you can tell it’s not natural. Indeed, a bay rum aftershave is an ideal choice.

Precaution for Use

It’s essential to consider fragrance allergies ranging from sneezing to severe respiratory upset. Also, if you note itching, blistering, or rashes on the skin discontinue the use of the product. Mainly, check the ingredient in a product and note what you’re allergic to and shop suitably.

The 5 Best Bay Rum Aftershaves

After using and reviewing several bay rum aftershaves, I’ve come up with top-five, and I’m confident you’ll find one for yourself from the list.

St Johns Aftershave

If you love smelling like you just came from a barbershop, then this is your ideal choice. It has features such as soothing properties, which is useful when you have a razor cut. It instantly relieves the burning sensation and replaces it with a mild cooling effect. It has an overpowering clove smell that makes you overlook the bay leaves scent. If you love musk, then you’ll love this product as it has a middle tone musk scent. Ideally, the scent lasts about 2 to 3 hours.

Another feature I appreciate about this product is the glass packaging that makes it look classy and worth displaying, unlike most other products on this list. This product has properties to soothe and softens your skin, and this, is a good thing mainly because we all want to avoid the razor bumps resulting from shaving. Layrite aftershave tightens your skin as it seals the pore, thus preventing infections on your skin. It also stimulates and cools your skin.


  • Calms skin
  • Affordable
  • Softens skin
  • Bay leaves, a scent that leaves you smelling fantastic and manly


  • Some people find it more expensive than other products containing the same ingredients

Pinaud Clubman Aftershave

The first thing that hits your nose after applying this lotion is the fragrance of clove and cinnamon or what you’d call exotic spices. You’ll smell the bay leaves scent after some minutes when the solution dries on your skin. The smell lingers for 4 to 5 hours, and some men use it as cologne. Immediately you apply it; you’ll feel sudden coolness, freshness, and toning of the skin. 

Although this product doesn’t have rum, it has SD-40 alcohol, an ingredient that works as a disinfectant for cuts, nicks, and razor bumps. When you look at the other elements on the label, you’ll find it has synthetic chemicals, most of which derived from essential oils.

One thing I love about this product is the masculine scent it leaves on my skin, making me feel more confident. I realized that using too much of it per shaving session irritates my skin. So I experimented by using a splash, and I admit I didn’t feel itchy or redness. Considering I’m a razor user, minor cuts are frequent. With the right amount of alcohol in this product, it soothes those cuts and soothes my skin.


  • Manufactured in the USA, thus you can be sure of the quality
  • Affordable
  • Sensational smell
  • Soothes cuts and razor bumps
  • Intoxicant ingredients


  • Can be irritating if you have highly sensitive skin over synthetic chemicals

Barberry Coast Shave Co.

Barberry Coast Shave Co Aftershave is a non-greasy aftershave characterized by anti-inflammatory properties. It lacks pungent smell like that of the original bay rum aftershave, but its close. I appreciate this product considering it has a typical smell and doesn’t leave residue on my beards. Moreover, the scent is not overpowering and thus does not choke everyone in the room. It has a clove scent that leaves you feeling refreshed.

Another useful feature is the quality ingredients the manufacturer uses, and it’s a good thing considering you put these ingredients on a sensitive part of the skin. Also, the elements determine the results of using the product. Barberry Coast Shave Co aftershave leaves your skin invigorated, toned, and disinfected. I appreciate this feature as I’m assured of protection against bacteria and fungi, causing germs from penetrating my skin. I also find this product ideal for those who have irritable skin such as mine because it has soothing characteristics and anti-inflammatory properties.


  • An exotic and spicy fragrance
  • Hand made in the Dominican Republic
  • Soothes your skin and leaves it feeling invigorated
  • Uses bay leaves and not chemicals mimicking the scent


  • Some users determined that the smell is a little too sweet

Lucky Tiger Aftersahve

This product is one of the most affordable aftershaves on my list. Besides, it has features such as immediate cooling effect relieving your skin. It has a bay rum scent that quickly fades. Something I disliked about this aftershave is how it’s greasy, and you can quickly identify that if you’ve previously used more exceptional products

Nonetheless, after using the aftershave several times, your skin will adapt. Although the packaging looks neat and classy on the picture, it might be disappointing when you receive it.

Besides all that, the product tightens and tone the skin. It relieves razor cuts and seals the pores preventing fungi and bacteria from penetrating. Although the manufacturer of this product doesn’t use rum, they use AD-40 alcohol that acts as a disinfectant, and thus, the product is ideal when you have cuts or razor bumps.


  • Affordable
  • Refreshing and cool
  • Stimulates skin


  • Not scented
  • Feels greasy

 Taylor of Old Bond Street

This is my favourite product, especially because the brand infuses the genuine bay leaves and rum. The fragrance is spicy and exotic and will leave sillage wherever you pass. The aroma is strong after you apply but soon fades, and that’s a characteristic of authentic bay rum aftershave. The bay leaves scent is, however, activated once you engage in an activity such as walking or movement, and thus, this product is not only an aftershave but can be used as a cologne. Essentially, fragrances come in three notes- top where the smell is choking, middle note that is soothing, and not so strong. It’s in the middle note that the fragrance of this product settles.

Another feature I love about this product is the soothing properties. The effect is immediate as you first experience an alcohol burning sensation that turns into a pleasant warming sensation. It is like sitting by the fire on a cold night. This product reminds me of the old bottle of aftershave I used at 9 years when I didn’t have any signs of growing beards. 


  • Clove and citrus scent as the top note fragrance and lay leaves as the middle note leaving you smelling exotic throughout the day
  • Use of high-quality ingredients
  • Immediate soothing of cuts, razor bumps and generally your skin
  • Creates long-lasting hold over a moustache
  • Seals pore to prevent bacteria from penetrating your skin after a shave.


  • Considering some manufacturers are using fancier containers such as glass and metal flask, the manufacturer of this product could use better packaging other than plastic.

Our Choice

Although St Johns Bay Rum is slightly unaffordable to some people, it takes the day. It comprises of original bay leaves and not synthetic chemicals and Jamaican rum. While other aftershave products are perfect, they either have pure bay leaves and another alcohol other than Jamaican rum or synthetic chemically derived bay leaves and alcohol.

My top choice is affordable, considering it has natural ingredients, is ideal for sensitive skin, and has an exotic and long-lasting fragrance giving you a manly scent.

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on email
Share on print

We have partnered with Duke Cannon to offer the best deal on their supply drop worth $75! If you click on the button below, we will take you to their special page where you can save 33%.

8 thoughts on “What Is The Best Bay Rum Aftershave In 2021?”

  1. Magazin Online Cosmetice La Reduceri

    You actually make it seem so easy with your presentation but I find this topic
    to be really something that I think I would never understand.
    It seems too complicated and very broad for me. I am looking forward for
    your next post, I’ll try to get the hang of it!

  2. rotund dur verde

    Hey! This is my first visit to your blog! We are a group of volunteers
    and starting a new project in a community in the same niche.
    Your blog provided us valuable information to work on. You have done a outstanding job!

  3. Politica de Confidentialitate

    This article will help the internet visitors for setting up new web site or even a weblog from start
    to end.

  4. cele mai bune tusuri de ochi

    Having read this I thought it was very informative.
    I appreciate you taking the time and effort to put this short
    article together. I once again find myself spending a significant amount of time both reading and
    posting comments. But so what, it was still worth

  5. Admiring the time and effort you put into your website and in depth information you offer.

    It’s good to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the same
    out of date rehashed information. Wonderful read!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top